Five Criteria for Choosing a Marketing Agency
A practical checklist covering reporting, contract terms, draft review, account ownership, and tying performance metrics to revenue when selecting an agency.
- BY
- MXFACTORY
- PUBLISHED
- Reading time
- 3 min read
Look at How They Work, Not Just the Proposal
Agency proposals tend to look alike. What separates good outcomes from bad ones is how the agency actually operates day to day. Check the five areas below before signing, and you can avoid most of the friction that appears later.
Reporting and Draft Review
Late or vague reporting means you learn about problems after the fact. Agree on these up front:
- Cadence and format: set a regular rhythm, such as a weekly summary and a monthly results report, and confirm you will receive them in a consistent template.
- Content: reports should show progress against goals, analysis of causes, and proposals for the next period, not just a list of tasks done.
- Contact person: ask whether the people you met during the pitch are the ones who will run your account.
- Draft review process: define who reviews content and ad copy before it goes live, by when, and how many revision rounds are included. Note how urgent changes are handled.
Without a review process, unapproved copy can go out, or slow approvals can delay the schedule. Naming a single approver on your side also helps.
Contract Length and Termination Terms
A longer term can make it easier for an agency to invest in your account, but it is harder to exit if the fit is poor. Confirm:
- Minimum term and whether the contract auto-renews
- Penalties for early termination and refund rules for prepaid fees
- Notice period and format (written notice, email, and so on)
- Whether ad spend and agency fees are billed separately
- Handover scope after termination: files, original creative, and data
Consider proposing a short pilot period, with a move to the full contract only if agreed criteria are met.
Ownership of Channel Accounts
This is the most common source of disputes. Ad accounts, analytics tools, the website, social channels, and the domain should in principle be created under your company's name, with the agency granted access only.
- Confirm your company is the account creator and top-level administrator.
- Give agency staff only the permissions they need.
- State in the contract who holds the copyright and usage rights for deliverables such as images, videos, and documents.
- Make sure account history and data remain intact after the contract ends.
If an agency runs everything under its own accounts, you may lose the data and assets you built the moment you part ways.
Connecting Metrics to Revenue
Impressions, clicks, and follower counts measure activity, not business results. Define metrics that carry through to revenue.
- Map your sales flow first, in stages such as inquiry, consultation, quote, and contract.
- Assign a metric to each stage, such as inquiries, consultation conversion, and contracts closed.
- Set up a way to trace which channel each inquiry came from, such as dedicated contact points, form fields, or links to your sales records.
- Ask the agency to report activity metrics and business metrics separately.
Because your sales records live on your side, your sales team and the agency need a regular session to judge lead quality by the same standard. Base targets on your current performance, and be wary of any proposal that guarantees results.
Summary and Next Steps
Before you decide, build a comparison table and ask every candidate the same questions:
- Reporting cadence, format, and contact person
- Draft review process and revision scope
- Contract term, termination conditions, and handover scope
- Account ownership and rights to deliverables
- Performance metrics tied to your sales stages
Agencies that answer concretely and are willing to put it in writing tend to make steadier partners. MXFACTORY helps mid-sized and small companies review how their marketing is run.
NEXT STEP
Let's start with a diagnosis.
One team handles AI development, branding websites and marketing. Tell us where you are, and we will decide together what to do first.
This post is general guidance. Every company is different, so review it against your own situation before applying it.
Keep reading
- Enterprise AX TransformationWhere to Start with Enterprise AX: From Task Inventory to Pilot to Scale DecisionA practical guide for company leaders on starting AI transformation: inventory work, pick repetitive tasks, run a small pilot, and decide whether to scale.Read →
- Enterprise AX TransformationToo Many AX Ideas? A Scoring Method for Deciding What to Do FirstRank AX project candidates by frequency, time spent, cost of errors, data readiness, and owner commitment, and learn which projects to avoid early on.Read →
- AI DevelopmentAdding AI to Company Work in the Right Order: From Document Cleanup to System IntegrationAdopt AI in five stages, from document cleanup to search, drafting, automation and system integration, preparing the right things at each step.Read →